Mountain States Legal Foundation Logo

Stop Union Abuse - Donate Here

Today, 52% of union members in America work for governments and get paid by taxpayers. To end their abuses, MSLF sued in Boise, where, in violation of the Idaho Constitution, the teacher’s union president is paid by the school district, without teaching a class or providing any service to school children. In addition, union members get paid time off for union activities—meetings, protests, and political events! In a recent election, voters were told they had to approve increased property taxes or else schools would have to cut staff and class sizes would grow larger. What the voters were NOT told was that the school district was paying funds directly to the union!

Freedom Club Level - $1,000  

The Freedom Club recognizes magnanimous supporters who provide an annual individual contribution of $1,000 or more.  The Freedom Club was instituted in 1982 to honor supporters who constitute the bedrock of MSLF's ability to defend constitutional liberties and the rule of law. 

 Membership Level - $25 

The Litigator, MSLF’s quarterly newsletter, is the indispensable tool for staying informed regarding the latest in MSLF’s precedent-setting, nationally-significant, public-interest litigation. The Litigator, which is mailed on the first working day of February, May, August, and November, is sent free of charge to all who provide annual support of $25 or more.

Donate $50 to MSLF and receive a free copy of Sagebrush Rebel (either the hardcover or the unabridged audiobook) -- the untold and fascinating story of Sagebrush Rebel Ronald Reagan, his courageous natural resources and environmental policies, and why the lessons taught by Reagan are worth relearning today.

Donate $50 to MSLF and receive a free copy of Summary Judgement:  25 Years of Condemning Treachery, Tyranny, and Injustice -- William Perry Pendley’s collection of his favorite hard-hitting monthly columns decrying breaches of the rule of law, abridgment of constitutional liberties, and unwise public policies. 

Idaho Freedom Foundation v. Independent School District Of Boise City

Issue:

Whether Idaho school districts should be using taxpayer dollars to subsidize union activities?

Plaintiff:

Idaho Freedom Foundation, an Idaho non-profit corporation; Rachel Gilbert

Defendant:

Independent School District of Boise City; Nancy Gregory, Maria Greeley, A. J. Balukoff, Dave Wagers, Troy Rhon, Doug Park, Brian Cronin, Don Coberly, Coby Dennis, all in their official capacities as members of the Board of Trustees of the Independent School District of Boise City; and Boise Education Association

Court:

District Court of the Fourth Judicial District of the State of Idaho, in and for Ada County
Ongoing discussion with MSLF's clients

Idaho’s Constitution reads, “No county, city, town, township, board of education, or school district, or other subdivision, shall lend, or pledge the credit or faith thereof directly or indirectly, in any manner, to, or in aid of any individual, association or corporation, for any amount or for any purpose whatever, or become responsible for any debt, contract or liability of any individual, association or corporation in or out of this state.”  Art. VIII, § 4.  In addition, Art. XII, § 4 provides, “No county, town, city, or other municipal corporation, by vote of its citizens or otherwise, shall ever become a stockholder in any joint stock company, corporation or association whatever, or raise money for, or make donation or loan its credit to, or in aid of, any such company or association....”  These so-called Gift Clauses bar state and local governments from using taxpayer money to benefit private interests.

Nonetheless, the Boise Independent School District signed a Master Contract with the Boise Education Association that provides, “The Association president shall be allowed a leave of absence for his/her term of office with salary and benefits to be paid by the Association for the time that the president is released from teaching duties.  The District shall reimburse the Association the cost of salary and benefits of a first year teacher…,” that is about $35,000; in addition, she accrues sick leave, vacation, and retirement.  The district also grants paid leave to employees attending union events.

On August 31, 2015, the Idaho Freedom Foundation (IFF), a Boise non-partisan educational research institute and government watchdog, and James Auld, a Boise resident and IFF member, sued the school district and school and union officials in Idaho’s Fourth Judicial District Court in Ada County seeking an order severing the offending contract language, barring the provision of paid leave, and awarding of attorneys’ fees. In October of 2015, Defendants filed an answer; discovery is now complete.

On August 10, 2016, IFF filed a motion to amend the complaint to challenge the new Master Contract and to add Rachel Gilbert, an IFF donor and Boise resident, as a party.  Defendants filed motions for summary judgment.  On September 16, 2016, the court heard argument on the pending motions.

On October 25, 2016, the court issued an order holding that IFF and Mr. Auld did not have standing, and denying Ms. Gilbert’s request to join the case.  On December 1, 2016, the court proposed a judgment that the case be dismissed with prejudice.  IFF filed an objection, arguing that, because the case was deciding on lack of standing, any judgment should be without prejudice.  The court heard argument on the proposed judgment on January 3, 2017.  On January 13, 2017, the court entered judgment in favor of the District and the Association on all claims.  On January 26, 2017, the parties filed a joint stipulation, in which plaintiffs waived their appeal rights in exchange for the District and the Association waiving any right to seek attorneys’ fees and expenses.

 

No Status Updates
  • Idahoans Disappointed With School District’s Union Funding Ruling

    Oct 25, 2016
    Idahoans relying on their State’s constitutional bar on the use of public funds to finance union activity today expressed disappointment with a State court’s dismissal of a suit seeking to end unconstitutional expenditures by a school district that benefit union officials.
  • Idahoans Seek to Amend School District Lawsuit for Union Activity

    Aug 11, 2016
    Idahoans relying on their State’s constitutional bar on the use of public funds to finance union activity today sought to amend their lawsuit against a school district and school and union officials seeking to end all unconstitutional expenditures.
  • Idahoans Sue School District For Funding Union Activity

    Aug 31, 2015
    Idahoans relying on their State’s constitutional bar on the use of public funds to finance union activity today sued a school district and school and union officials to end all unconstitutional expenditures.
No Documents